(Volume: 2, Issue: 5)
Does references have a role during journal’s peer review?
Have you experienced a situation, wherein the journal rejects your research article before passing it to the peer review process and the reason is ‘no proper references and citations’? If so, what are references? What is the significance of adding references to an article? Why do journals show importance to references and judge an article based on it before performing the double-blind peer review? What the authors has to do?
Let’s have a glimpse at it…
Image Courtesy: www.freepik.com
References- What it means
References in research article represent the sources, which were used to build the research and its associated article. It might be a journal publication, conference publication, books, datasets and other web sources having relevancy to the article.
References-The significance
Proper citing of references has numerous significances. The very first significance is that it imparts research integrity. If there is no research integrity, there will be no further research developments. The second most important significance is that it acts as a proof for the research being made in a truthful sense. It means that the research is not fake and it was built on findings from prior original research of the same or different author. The next significance is that allows the readers to recognize the field under which the research is carried out. In addition, proper citing of references enables future researchers to know and get access to relevant data repositories. Not only that, it improves the visibility of the research. In all, the references showcase all the sources, which are needed to perform and distribute research.
Why journals show importance?
The references play a crucial role right from the submission to the acceptance of a research article. This is because of the following reasons: (i) Credibility of research that it is performed only based on the existing research, which are provided in the reference section; (ii) To check the level of plagiarism between the submitted article and its associated references; (iii) To aid in the double-blind peer review, as the references alone speak to prove the superiority of the proposed approach; (iv) Ensuring research integrity and (v) To guide the researchers, especially to achieve a high-quality research in a specific domain.
What the authors have to do?
The authors should come to know about the real significance of adding references to their research article and cite the references without fail. If the authors believe that the references could make their research more visible across nations, it is equally important for them to credit the original authors, from whom they have inherited their research base. In this way, the authors can encourage research integrity. The authors should strictly adhere to the journals’ reference formatting rules, as they are framed in a manner to ensure that not even a single piece of data is lost for the future researchers.
Hence, The Research Seer’s Rationale on “Does references have a role during journal’s peer review?” is:
“References are responsible for Research Integrity and Reproducibility”